Don’t forget another point - Shabazz Napier is far more “pro ready” than Burke and better at every facet of the game.
Napier’s summer league stats so far: 9.6 points, 3.7 assists, 4.2 TOs, .274% from the floor, .195% from three. Of course the summer league is moderately relevant at best, completely irrelevant at worst, but thus far he’s not exactly making you look like a genius.
Matt, you are entitled to your opinion about Burke, and it’s entirely possible you will eventually turn out to be correct. It would be no different than me, sitting here today, saying “Johnny Manziel doesn’t have the maturity to be an NFL quarterback.” I might be right, I might not be right. It’s something that may not get decided today, or even in 2-3 years.
My issue with your Burke comments was that I think it’s nearly impossible to conclude, after a rookie season in which Trey posted pretty decent numbers, that he’s nothing more than a bench guy for a good team. It’s just way too early to make that call, especially given the work ethic Trey has demonstrated during his career thus far. You may turn out to be right, but my issue is with your reasoning, which I think is wrong.
I think two things: (1) your basketball frame of reference is that you love athleticism - I sometimes think you would be ecstatic if we recruited a team full of Brent Petway and Corey Sanders types; and (2) you like to make snap judgments about Michigan players, often tinged with a bit of controversy, to get a rise out of the board - like your long diatribe about how DJ Wilson is not athletic. Or the “Battle isn’t coming here” stuff. Again, you may turn out to be right - since there are like 10 schools chasing him, the odds that he picks one school are indeed pretty low. But unless you’re an insider with respect to his recruitment, you simply don’t know anything more than the rest of us. Three years ago, when we were fighting Duke, Kentucky and Florida for McGary, I’ll bet you would have said then, “He isn’t coming here.”
Look, I think you’re knowledgeable about basketball, and I generally enjoy the discussions that you participate in, but I think you enjoy starting controversial discussions. And I’m not even saying there’s a problem with that, as long as the insults don’t get too personal, but just own it.