My take is that it was run poorly
You can win without both
Providence is not Northwestern. They have a decent history. They have had good coaches and good seasons in the past. Itās a good school in a good city. I credit Cooley for consistency but he hasnāt taken them to a next level. No deep tourney runs. No conference titles. He doesnāt have a niche that I can see that would make me want to take a chance on him (like JBās offense or Smartās Havoc D coming out of VCU). I donāt think heād be a disaster here, but Iām having trouble seeing anything better than 4th place.
If we are going with coaches with mediocre track records, Iād rather go with Smart. His floor is higher as well as his ceiling IMO.
1 Like
Yea, donāt let pesky stats get in the way. Okay then, how about he doesnāt pass the eye test for me. Has anyone ever, other than you, watched a Providence game and thought ādamn thatās a well-coached teamā?
1 Like
If it really is down to these three, then I am VERY strongly in the Juwan camp. I had warmed up to Shaka, but the others would be very disappointing and could have a lowish floor.
9 Likes
Yeah, I think Juwan is the strongest candidate of the three. You know what youāre getting with Cooley and itās fine enough, but the ceiling is higher with Howard. Yaklich I think is a courtesy and, for all we know, so is Cooley.
Wow I am team Juwan all the way. Shouldnāt these search firms try to remove their biases? How dumb is it that he becomes a candidate for us because the guy working at the search firm was his AD for a bit.
Shaka>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Cooley. I canāt understate this enough. I even was starting to get excited about Shaka. He was 1b for me with Juwan
8 Likes
Given Wardeās statement about wanting to hire someone with head coaching experience, I think he had to at least interview one candidate that does. Cooley has that connection to the search firm and may benefit from getting the attention. Heās on solid ground at Providence, unlike a couple of others.
2 Likes
I hate getting into this type of stuff but this should be a major selling point for juwan or Cooley when recruiting against b1g teams
2 Likes
Iām still not writing Shaka off from this. But if itās these three Iām going
Juwan
Yaklich
Cooley
11 Likes
Going from the Shaka-Howard debate to a potential Cooley hire is very underwhelming.
3 Likes
And it was already underwhelming from basically the start. The bar is being lowered by the day smh.
1 Like
Goodman didnāt say they were the only 3 candidates or even the 3 leading ones. Just serious candidates because he knows about their interviews. Jordan and Smart have been rumored to want to keep any interviews quiet.
1 Like
Iām gonna triple down on the Yak train. āNot ready to be a head coachā is not an argument I buy into. To some extent, every coachās first head coaching gig is bound to have some risk. While it is a big leap to Big Ten ball from say a low majorāif heās got the ability to coach, heās got the ability to coach. Iām unsure how a few years of rebuilding a bottom feeder will somehow exponentially increase his abilities. Give me Yak!!! 
1 Like
BP3 werenāt you a Providence supporter earlier in the year?
How is that a recruiting selling point
Sam said Shaka seems to be behind Cooley. Which is wild to me. Canāt think of an argument for that.
6 Likes
Yeah, on a purely basketball level it makes no sense. Maybe there are rumors of Smart on the recruiting trail being up to no good? Idk. It really does make no sense. Someone on here called Cooley a poor manās Smart. Think thatās 100% accurate. Thatās why I went all in on Yaklich. All options seem unappealing to a degree given the market right now.
Selling point is not how I would put it. It might be an advantage in some recruitments.