Yeah Yak is a gem. The new guy has to see his defensive numbers and be impressed.
2 Likes
Oh, I completely agree. Management here is in a tough spot. I have no illusions that the will do whatever it takes to keep Yak. I would. Manuel wonāt. I just think talent and certain intangibles of ādoing things the right wayā all make Yak a canāt lose. Heās an educator too. Indispensable to me.
I agree with you, and to that point, Bennett had to win 3 games that were absolute coin tosses at the end (maybe even worse odds than that) to win the championshipā¦Purdue, Auburn, TT.
1 Like
Yak is a strong recruiter too. Smart feels like settling for a good fit. A high floor, but I donāt like his ceiling. I guess Smart is uninspiring enough that Iād rather gamble with Juwan or Yak. Iām not that worried about their floors.
Would a couple of bad years really be worse than a string of bubble teams? Smart could hang around a long time with so-so results. It would be a lot easier for the AD to admit hiring Yak or Juwan was a mistake and move on.
Yeah man. Iām with you. His title run is just as much due to luck as all the defeats. Itās easy to get overvalue tournament wins when evaluating coaches. Thatās all I really meant.
2 Likes
I would be OK with giving Yak a shot. Yes, itās a gamble to promote a guy whoās never been a HC before. But heās delivered two top 5 national defenses. He did the unthinkable - he made Beilein-coached teams be more known for their D. The way the game has changed to be more centered on the three and spreading the court, playing elite D may be the way to differentiate yourself now. (Plus he has some familiarity with our offensive system, anyway.)
2 Likes
Iād also take Yak and Juwan over Smart.
I think if Juwan is head coach, possibly Yak stays.
Yak head coach, probably retain Haynes.
3 Likes
But Barnes has years of success at Texas to point to. Shaka has a single tourney run.
And I say heās a bad developer of talent because the talent he gets doesnāt really get better while theyāre there and arenāt used in an effective way. I donāt see a reason to expect us to be more than a bubble team with him in charge. Thatās essentially what heās done with teams his entire career
Smart news definitely sounds like people close to Smart trying to generate the buzz. Heās closer to the hot seat at Texas than he is getting the job at Michigan. I assume theyāre trying to get him a raise or extension by making him seem like a possibility to Michigan.
3 Likes
This would make total sense. I donāt Smart being a candidate at allllll. Yikes. He is close to being done at UT. I live in Texas and he isnāt particularly well liked by alumni or fansā¦
2 Likes
Has Prohm gotten any mention?
1 Like
Shaka Smart would be the definition of someone falling upwards. Seems like a great guy, but that man is getting fired after this coming season unless something REALLY turns around.
1 Like
Take a look through Texasā recruiting classes over the past 5 years. Now go look at their results. That should change some minds on Shaka.
3 Likes
I just say Michigan go full send for Mike White and make it happen 
Shaka Smart grew up a Michigan fan I believe. Between that, if true, and the fact that his job at Texas is tenuous, Iām guessing he actually is interested in the job. A few years ago I recall Michigan fans praying Smart would be interested in Michigan after Beilein left. Fans everywhere for every college were praying heād be available whenever they had a opening.
1 Like
Guys is Yaklich had his exact track record but at, likeā¦Purdue - would there be a soul seriously suggesting him?
Itās a bad idea.
2 Likes
Heād absolutely be suggested as a replacement for Painter.
When you have a strong program, continuity is a good thing.
Heās not a great idea, but heās a better idea than some proven mediocre options.
1 Like
Continuity matters for 12 months, tops. Hiring the right coach matters for years.
2 Likes
Choosing between him and Moser, fine. The idea that heās better than White, Prohm, or, yes, Shaka Smart, seems crazy to me.