I watched Easley for essentially the entire UM camp. I lean toward agreeing with you, but not fully on board yet.
First off, Easley is only 6'4.5 - 6'5, and that is the issue in a nutshell. He's not really big enough or athletic enough to play PF in the B10, but he is strong. I've seen him handle the ball on film in HS, and he's certainly shown some things, but didn't display that at the UM Camp.
Where I disagree is the shotmaking, Easely hit several shots from both mid-range and distance, both off the dribble and the catch. For context, Easley actually shot the ball better than Zak Irvin doing an identical drill (probably says more about Zak than Easley). Easley shot 7/14 from distance during one 3 point drill I was attentive to. His mechanics are inconsistent, and his shot can be flat at times.
In terms of scrimmages, a lot of people are failing to provide full context. Easley's team had no subs at ALL. Essentially he played 1.5 - 2 hrs straight without a break. Nobody at the HS level can go that long and still produce at optimal level.
Bottom line for me is this - I need to see more of him. And I will very soon, he will be at my showcase on October 9th, and I'm curious to see how he does vs better comp in relation to the UM camp.