Could they? Sure you could try it. I also just think that if you keep taking guys who are very similar, the depth chart starts to play a role.
You can tell Johns he's your 4 man, Tyson is the glue between multiple positions and a shooter, and then pitch Ignas and Hunter on being the guy -- I think Jerome Hunter referred to it as 'the wolf' -- who can go and hunt shots on the wing and be a big time scorer. Hard to sell the 2nd wolf.
PS... Having a Hunter Tyson and a Jerome Hunter on the recruiting radar can be very confusing.